7 Tax Preparers in Shrewsbury, NJ

Browse verified tax preparers in Shrewsbury, New Jersey. Compare providers and find contact information.

David M. Muldowney, Jr., CPA

★★★★½ (17 reviews)
595 Shrewsbury Ave Suite 206A, Shrewsbury, NJ 07702
(732) 431-4332
Website: www.muldowneycpa.com
Hours: {"Friday":["8 AM–5 PM"],"Monday":["8 AM–5 PM"],"Saturday":["Closed"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["8 AM–5 PM"],"Tuesday":["8 AM–5 PM"],"Wednesday":["8 AM–5 PM"]}

Hoover & Ruther Financial Services

★★★★★ (7 reviews)
1161 Broad St # 112, Shrewsbury, NJ 07702
(732) 842-6663
Hours: {"Friday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Monday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Saturday":["Closed"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Tuesday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Wednesday":["9 AM–5 PM"]}

Tracy Joel D CPA

★★★★★ (3 reviews)
39 Ave at the Cmns Ste. 210, Shrewsbury, NJ 07702
(732) 389-1414
Hours: {"Friday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Monday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Saturday":["Closed"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Tuesday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Wednesday":["9 AM–5 PM"]}

Steven T. Spinello, CPA

★★★★★ (1 reviews)
476 Broad St, Shrewsbury, NJ 07702
(732) 747-2711
Hours: {"Friday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Monday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Saturday":["10 AM–3 PM"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Tuesday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Wednesday":["9 AM–5 PM"]}

Palmeri Russell J CPA

★★★★★ (1 reviews)
729 Broad St, Shrewsbury, NJ 07702
(732) 747-7777
Hours: {}

Pistilli & Co

★★★★★ (1 reviews)
429 Broad St, Shrewsbury, NJ 07702
(732) 219-6660
Website: www.pistillicpa.com
Hours: {"Friday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Monday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Saturday":["Closed"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Tuesday":["9 AM–5 PM"],"Wednesday":["9 AM–5 PM"]}

Carroll & Associates LLC

243 Garden Rd, Shrewsbury, NJ 07702
(973) 542-1841
Website: carroll-associates.com
Hours: {"Friday":["8:30 AM–5:30 PM"],"Monday":["8:30 AM–5:30 PM"],"Saturday":["Closed"],"Sunday":["Closed"],"Thursday":["8:30 AM–5:30 PM"],"Tuesday":["8:30 AM–5:30 AM"],"Wednesday":["8:30 AM–5:30 AM"]}

About Tax Preparers in Shrewsbury, NJ

Shrewsbury, New Jersey, is a community with a mix of small businesses, retail establishments, and commuting professionals. Its proximity to major highways and commercial corridors means many residents face complex tax situations involving self-employment income, investment earnings, or multi-state returns. Whether you run a local boutique or work remotely for an out-of-state employer, the tax rules can quickly become more than a simple software program can handle.

Finding a qualified tax preparer in Shrewsbury can help you navigate these specific challenges. A local professional understands New Jersey’s state tax requirements and can identify deductions you might miss on your own. This is especially valuable if your financial situation includes rental properties, freelance work, or recent life changes like marriage or starting a business.

BeforeTaxUSA.com makes it straightforward to browse tax preparers in the Shrewsbury area. You can compare credentials, read verified client reviews, and choose someone who fits your needs—without the guesswork. No matter how straightforward or complex your taxes are, having the right preparer can save you time and give you confidence in your filing.

Frequently Asked Questions

What qualifications should a tax preparer have?

At minimum, a paid tax preparer must have an IRS-issued PTIN. Look for additional credentials like Enrolled Agent (EA) status, CPA license, or completion of the IRS Annual Filing Season Program. These indicate higher levels of training and accountability.

How much does tax preparation cost?

Simple individual returns (W-2 income only) typically cost $100-$300. Returns with itemized deductions, self-employment income, or rental properties can cost $300-$800 or more. Always ask for a fee estimate upfront before committing.

What documents do I need to bring to my tax preparer?

Bring all W-2s, 1099 forms, records of deductible expenses, last year's tax return, Social Security numbers for all family members, bank account information for direct deposit, and any IRS correspondence you have received.

BeforeTaxUSA.com is a free informational directory. Listings are compiled from publicly available data and do not constitute an endorsement or recommendation. Verify credentials, licensing, and reviews independently before engaging any professional. Listings appear in no particular order unless otherwise noted.

Business owners: to update or remove a listing, email [email protected].

CPAsAccountantsTax PreparersBookkeepers